After Prime Minister Narendra Modi asked his ministers not to speak to media directly, there have been media reports that he may follow his Gujarat Model here too. This is what Scroll.in wrote
These instructions may well be the first serious step to turn New Delhi into Gandhinagar, where during Modi’s three terms as chief minister, members of his cabinet would not speak to the press unless they had obtained permission from him. Even the customary press briefings after the state cabinet meetings – which in other states are addressed by ministers – are either not held at all in Gujarat or are addressed by spokesmen of the state government.
The opposition has, naturally, seen it as disempowering ministers. But the question is: is it really disempowering or is it trying to cut off media from the communications channel? other than, of course, the “official” policy communications, which ministry spokespersons will continue to do?
What the media has failed to notice is that Modi may be directly or indirectly influencing his ministers to “communicate directly” with people, as he himself has done, choosing to speak to media only when he wants and “in his terms”.
Twitter, his preferred channel, is largely one-sided communications; can be better managed than a press conference to show what you want to show; and once in a while, both genuine compliments/suggestions as well as planted ones can be responded to give that “interaction with common people” feeling.
Here is a list of ministers with Twitter accounts and their number of followers. While Modi himself leads the pack with Sushama Swaraj (a veeteran tweeple) as a distant No 2, others are way behind, though some of them are catching up fast. Arun Jaitley, for example, started this account only in November 2013 and has already close to 350,000 followers.
Union Ministers on Twitter (Click to enlarge)
The bar graph, of course, shows the number of followers (it is not exactly to scale but the mentioned numbers are actual), as of 9th June 2014.
But what is more interesting is how long they have been on Twitter, represented in the chart through use of different shades. Out of 32 cabinet ministers and ministers of state with independent charge, as many as 24 (that is 75%) are in Twitter. That is fairly high, as compared to the UPA government.
But what is interesting and supports the theory that they may be trying to impress their leader is the time of their joining. As many as 10 0f those have joined Twitter after Modi was officially anointed the chief of campaign committee in June 2013. As many as 14 have joined after he emerged as the No 1 prime ministerial candidate. And if you leave out genuine prolific users such as Modi himself, Sushma Swaraj, Nirmala Sitharaman and Smriti Irani, there are just a handful of them who have joined after 2011 but before Modi emerged as the No 1 leader; in other words, for natural reasons. There is absolutely no one among the ministers who is between 2 -3 years old in Twitter.
In fact, those who are wondering what made Modi choose Smriti Irani as a cabinet minister with a plum portfolio (others are either veterans, come with a professional background like Gen VK Singh or who have proven themselves in party work such as Dharmendra Pradhan and Piyush Goyal), the Twitter stats may give a clue. In Modi’s “virtually real” world, she has delivered the best performance, creating the largest follower base in Twitter after Modi and Sushma Swaraj, the later herself an aspirant for PM post before Modi’s emergence.
Here is a list of all the cabinet ministers and ministers of state with independent charge with their age and Twitter handle, just for your reference.
|D. V. Sadananda Gowda||61||@DVSBJP|
|Ram Vilas Paswan||67||@iramvilaspaswan|
|Ravi Shankar Prasad||59||@rsprasad_bjp|
|Ashok Gajapati Raju||62||NA|
|Narendra Singh Tomar||56||NA|
|Thawar Chand Gehlot||66||NA|
|Radha Mohan Singh||64||@singhradhamohan|
|Vijay Kumar Singh||63||@Gen_VKSIngh|
|Inderjit Singh Rao||63||@Rao_InderjitS|
|Santosh Kumar Gangwar||66||NA|
|Shripad Yasso Naik||61||NA|
|Dr. Jitendra Singh||42||NA|